RV Water Heaters: Tank, Tankless and Hybrid

Side of an open Jayco pop-up camper with louvered access panels along the lower wall, a garden hose connected, blue water jugs and a rooftop air conditioner
Photo: Korey99 / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
In this guide
  1. The three types compared
  2. Tank heaters: Suburban vs Atwood
  3. The dripping relief valve is usually normal
  4. Tankless: Girard and Truma
  5. Hybrid: gas and electric together
  6. Never fire an empty tank
  7. Bypass and winterizing
  8. Which should you pick?
  9. Maintenance by type

Most RVs have a 6- or 10-gallon tank water heater that runs on propane, 120-volt electric, or both; a growing number have a tankless (on-demand) propane heater instead. For a couple taking short showers, a gas and electric tank is cheap to run, simple and works on campground power. For longer showers, families, or anyone tired of waiting 20 minutes between showers, a tankless unit such as the Girard GSWH-2 or Truma AquaGo delivers hot water as long as propane and water flow, at the cost of a minimum flow rate, more sensitivity to water pressure, and periodic descaling. The “hybrid” option in between is either a tank with both gas and electric running at once, or a tankless unit with a small heated reserve.

Below: how each type works, real specs from the manufacturers, which tanks need an anode rod, the relief-valve drip that worries every new owner, bypass and winterizing, and how to choose.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Some brands linked below pay a bonus commission through Amazon Creator Connections. See /disclosure/.

The three types compared

Tank, propane onlyTank, gas + electric (“DE”)Tankless propane
ExampleSuburban SAW6DSuburban SAW6DE; Atwood/Dometic GC6AA-10EGirard GSWH-2; Truma AquaGo
Capacity6 or 10 gal6 or 10 galNo tank (AquaGo holds 1.3 L)
Gas inputAbout 8,800 to 12,000 BTU/h on 6-gal modelsSame, plus a 1,400–1,440 W element42,000 BTU/h (Girard); 20,000–60,000 BTU/h modulating (Truma)
RecoverySuburban SAW6D: 8.48 gal/h at a 100°F rise14.58 gal/h with both on (SAW6DE)Continuous while flow continues
12V drawSmall (igniter, controls)SmallGirard: under 3 A firing, about 0.2 A standby
Uses campground electricityNoYesNo (propane only on these models)
WinterizingDrain; bypassDrain; bypassDrain the unit; Girard says no bypass kit is needed
MaintenanceAnode (Suburban) or flushing (Atwood)SameDescaling, inlet filter
Best forBasic trailers, dry campersHookup campers who want free hot waterLong showers, families, full-timers

Sources: Suburban’s Advantage spec sheet, Girard’s GSWH-2 owner’s manual and Truma’s AquaGo product page, all read October 28, 2026; the Atwood/Dometic rating is from a retailer listing.

Tank heaters: Suburban vs Atwood

The two classic tank heaters are built differently, and that changes the maintenance.

Suburban uses a steel tank (porcelain-lined on the current Advantage line) protected by a sacrificial anode rod that also serves as the drain plug. The anode corrodes so the tank does not. Suburban’s manuals say to replace it yearly, and warn that RV antifreeze is corrosive to the anode, which is one reason to keep antifreeze out of the heater with a bypass. Pulling the anode to drain and inspect it is a 10-minute job with a 1-1/16-inch socket.

Atwood (now sold under the Dometic name) uses an aluminum tank with a protective interior cladding and a plastic drain plug. Atwood’s owner’s manual relies on flushing instead: it says flushing several times a year prolongs tank life, and that about two quarts stay in the bottom of the tank after draining, holding most of the corrosive particles. Do not fit a Suburban-style anode to an aluminum Atwood tank; owners report steel plugs seizing in the aluminum threads.

SuburbanAtwood / Dometic
TankSteel (porcelain-lined on Advantage models)Aluminum, clad interior
Corrosion protectionAnode rod, replace yearlyCladding; no anode
DrainRemove the anodeRemove the plastic plug
Rotten-egg odor fixReplace anode; flushAtwood: flush with 4 parts vinegar to 2 parts water
6-gal electric element1,440 W1,400 W (retailer listing)

Suburban’s 6-gallon Advantage spec sheet gives the cleanest recovery numbers published: 8.48 gallons per hour on propane, 6.10 on the electric element and 14.58 with both, measured for a 100°F rise from 30°F inlet water. In summer, with warmer inlet water, recovery is faster.

A white double RV kitchen sink with one basin covered, a single tall faucet with separate hot and cold handles, below a window
The two handles are the whole user interface for the water heater. What sits behind them, a tank, a tankless burner or a combination, decides how long the shower lasts. Photo: Flickr: iluvcocacola / CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The dripping relief valve is usually normal

Every tank heater has a pressure and temperature (P&T) relief valve on the outside. As water heats it expands, and an RV’s plumbing is a closed system, so pressure rises until the valve weeps. Atwood’s manual says plainly that weeping while the heater is running does not mean the valve is defective.

The tank is designed with an air gap at the top that cushions the expansion; over time the water absorbs it. Atwood’s procedure to restore it:

  1. Turn the water heater off and let it cool. The water must be cool before you open the valve.
  2. Turn off the incoming water supply (pump or city water).
  3. Open a hot water faucet inside.
  4. Pull the P&T valve lever straight out and let water flow until it stops.
  5. Let the valve snap shut, close the faucet and turn the water back on.

Atwood also says to operate the valve by hand at least once a year. If weeping returns quickly, its suggested permanent fixes are a relief valve on the cold inlet set to 100 to 125 psi, or a small diaphragm expansion tank on the cold line. A valve that drips constantly with the heater off, or leaks at the tank fitting rather than the valve, is a different problem; have it checked. Never plug a P&T valve.

Tankless: Girard and Truma

A tankless heater fires a large burner only when hot water is flowing, heating it on the way through a heat exchanger.

Girard GSWH-2. The owner’s manual lists 42,000 BTU per hour, a 12-volt draw under 3 amps, and 125 psi maximum water pressure. Three details matter in daily use:

  • It needs at least 0.80 gallon per minute at each hot faucet to fire. A trickle from a water-saving shower head or a half-open tap may not light it.
  • It works best on a pressurized supply of 45 psi or more; a weak or pulsing pump makes the temperature swing.
  • The user setting runs from 95°F to 124°F, and the manual notes performance drops when inlet water is colder than about 45°F.

The controller draws about 0.2 amp all the time, so Girard says to switch off its 12-volt power in storage or when dry camping. It also has a freeze-protection thermostat that fires the burner if the heat exchanger falls below 38°F and stops it above 58°F, but only if propane and 12-volt power are on, and it protects the heater only, not the rest of the plumbing.

Truma AquaGo. Truma’s product page lists a modulating burner of 20,000 to 60,000 BTU per hour on propane with 12-volt controls, a 1.3-liter internal water capacity, and “endless hot water even at high flow rates.” The control panel has eco and comfort modes; owner’s manual excerpts describe comfort mode as keeping a small reserve warm so hot water arrives sooner. That small heated reserve is what most marketing means by a “hybrid” tankless heater. Truma requires periodic decalcification: its FAQ says the flush takes roughly 8 gallons of water and ends with fault code 31, “Decalcification Complete.”

The tankless tradeoffs. Hot water takes as long to reach the faucet as the pipe run, the same as a tank. Very low flows may not fire the burner. Hard water scales the heat exchanger. And on these models, propane is the only heat source, so campground electricity cannot carry the load.

Hybrid: gas and electric together

The other kind of hybrid is simply a DE tank running on both sources. Propane alone heats faster than the element; both together recover fastest. On electric, the 1,440-watt element draws about 12 amps at 120 volts, which is significant on a 30-amp site with the air conditioner running. Before switching it on at a small campground pedestal, check your load in the RV electrical load calculator; the 30-amp vs 50-amp guide explains why the breaker trips.

Common pattern: electric only at hookups (free hot water, slow recovery), add propane when the family needs back-to-back showers, propane only when dry camping.

A compact motorhome bathroom with a toilet, a round vanity sink, wood cabinets with towels and a window
In a small RV bathroom the shower, sink and toilet share a few gallons of hot water, so heater capacity and recovery rate matter more than in a house. Photo: Seekater / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Never fire an empty tank

The quickest way to ruin a tank heater is to switch on the electric element before the tank is full; an element run dry burns out. Suburban’s instruction is to refill and purge all air from the tank and lines before lighting or applying power. Open a hot faucet until water runs without spurting, then switch the heater on. This matters most after de-winterizing, after sanitizing the fresh water system (see the sanitizing guide), and after draining the tank to change an anode.

Bypass and winterizing

Tank heaters must be drained and bypassed before freezing weather. The bypass valves, usually behind an access panel inside the RV, isolate the tank so antifreeze does not fill 6 or 10 gallons of it, and, for Suburban, so antifreeze does not attack the anode. The full sequence is in the winterizing guide.

Tankless units are easier. Girard’s manual says the small amount of water in the heat exchanger does not require a bypass kit; drain it and either blow out the lines or run antifreeze through per the RV maker’s instructions. Truma’s FAQ has you drain the system, pull the yellow Easy Drain lever and store the inlet filter separately for the winter. If you camp in freezing weather with the water system in use, the cold-weather camping guide covers what else freezes first.

Which should you pick?

Your situationBest fit
Weekend couple, mostly hookups6-gal DE tank on electric
Family with kids, back-to-back showersTankless, or 10-gal DE tank with both sources on
Dry camping, small batteryPropane tank (Suburban or Atwood); tankless works too but watch the 12V standby draw
Full-timing, long showersTankless (Truma or Girard), with a water softener or regular descaling in hard-water areas
Low water pressure or weak pumpTank; tankless needs flow and pressure

Replacing a tank with a tankless unit is often possible in the same wall opening, sometimes with an adapter frame, but check the propane line size (tankless burners need far more gas flow than a 10,000 BTU tank burner) and confirm the RV’s gas system can supply it; Girard’s manual lists this as a requirement. Propane system basics are in the propane guide.

Gear worth a look (affiliate links)

If the table points you to tankless, one propane option is the 60,000 BTU RV tankless water heater sold by NOVIEEX. Per the listing, it runs on LP propane with 12-volt DC controls, fits a 15 x 15 inch white access door, is CSA certified, and has smart temperature control and freeze prevention. The listing title does not state a minimum flow rate, so check that figure, and your propane line size as described above, before you order.RV Tankless Water Heater, 60,000 BTU Instant Hot Water System, 15"×15" White Access Panel, 12V DC LPG Propane with Smart Temperature Control & Freeze Prevention, CSA Certified for RVs and Campers$299.99Price as of November 16, 2026, 10:00 AM ET. Prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Maintenance by type

  • Suburban: pull the anode each season; replace when heavily pitted or roughly half gone, or yearly per Suburban. Flush sediment out with a tank wand while it is out.
  • Atwood/Dometic: flush several times a year; vinegar flush for odor; check the plastic plug’s threads and seal.
  • All tank heaters: exercise the P&T valve once a year; check the burner tube for insect nests after storage (Atwood’s manual lists a lazy yellow flame or delayed ignition as symptoms).
  • Tankless: descale on the maker’s schedule, clean the inlet filter, keep the exterior vent clear.

Figures above were read from Suburban’s Advantage spec sheet and manuals, the Atwood 4-E/10-E owner’s manual, Girard’s GSWH-2 owner’s manual and Truma’s AquaGo page and FAQ on October 28, 2026. Your heater’s rating plate and manual override anything here.

Frequently asked questions

How long does a 6-gallon RV water heater last in the shower?

Longer than 6 gallons suggests, because you mix it with cold water, but not long. Owners commonly describe it as about one short shower per tank. Recovery is the real limit: Suburban's spec sheet for its 6-gallon Advantage heater lists 8.48 gallons per hour on propane, 6.10 on the electric element and 14.58 with both on, for a 100°F temperature rise. Turning on gas and electric together roughly halves the wait between showers.

Does my RV water heater have an anode rod?

Suburban heaters do: their steel tanks rely on a sacrificial anode that doubles as the drain plug, and Suburban recommends replacing it yearly. Atwood (now Dometic) heaters use an aluminum tank with a protective interior cladding and a plastic drain plug, not an anode. Tankless heaters such as the Girard GSWH-2 and Truma AquaGo have no tank and no anode.

Is a tankless RV water heater worth it?

If you shower long or camp with a family, usually yes: hot water continues as long as propane and water flow. The tradeoffs are a minimum flow rate (Girard specifies 0.80 gallon per minute for each hot faucet), sensitivity to low water pressure, propane-only heating on most models, and periodic descaling. With a single couple taking short showers at hookups, a gas and electric tank heater is simpler and lets you heat with campground electricity.

Why is my RV water heater's relief valve dripping?

Usually because it is doing its job. Atwood's manual says weeping while the heater runs does not mean the valve is defective; water expands as it heats in the RV's closed system. Restore the air gap at the top of the tank (heater off, water supply off, open a hot faucet, pull the valve lever until flow stops). If it keeps weeping, Atwood suggests an expansion tank or a relief valve on the cold inlet.

Can I run the water heater on electric and propane at the same time?

On gas and electric (DE) tank models, yes, and that is the fastest way to recover: Suburban's figures go from 8.48 gallons per hour on gas alone to 14.58 with both. On a 30-amp site, remember the element draws about 12 amps (1,440 watts at 120 volts), which is a big share of your service when the air conditioner is running.